Carrierintel Safety Score: 66/100. 6 inspection violations in 12 months. Last inspected Feb 2026.
DOT 368073MC 1007795ActiveMotor CarrierInterstateSELECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA · $750,000 · 1 policyMONROE, IN
COMPANY
Authority since
2019-01-10
MCS-150
2025-03-31 · 6,255,000 mi (2024)
Fleet
150 units · 6 trailers · 186 drivers
Annual mileage (VMT)
6,255,000 mi (2024)
ADDRESS
Physical
101 N POLK ST MONROE, IN 46772
Mailing
2085 WAGNER ST VANDALIA, IL 62471
CONTACT
Phone
6182831119
Email
tina.zurcher@bestone.net
OFFICERS
Primary Officer
KRISTINA E ZURCHER
Title
SECRETARY
OPERATION & CARGO
Operation classification
Authorized For Hire
Specialty
General Freight
Cargo types
2
General FreightOther: TIRES, TUBES, WHEELS
Self-reported by the company on its latest MCS-150 filing (FMCSA census). Reflects what the carrier is authorized and equipped to haul, not actual recent loads. Specialty is our summary of the declared cargo mix.
AUTHORITY
93 mo
Active authority
INSURANCE
1 active
SELECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA
RISK GRADE
Minimal Risk
0 risk factors · 3 strengths
OOS RATE
8.2%
12 / 147 inspections
Carrierintel Safety Score
Rolling 12-month heuristic based on inspections, OOS, violations, crashes & fatalities. Not the official FMCSA SMS score.
66
out of 100
Fair
Markers: OOS inspection Crash Fatality
Fleet vs Reality
last 12 months · power-unit VINs from roadside inspections
1 policy(ies) on file · total max coverage $750,000
SUMMARY
Low crash rate (0.7 per 100 trucks/yr)
92% clean inspections
Active insurance on file
INDUSTRY REPORTS
ELD Tampering — Carriers cited for ELD tampering under 49 CFR § 395.8(e), by carrier and state.
Top Violations — The ten most-cited FMCSA violation codes of the last 30 days.
Phantom Fleets — Declared power units against the vehicles seen at roadside inspections.
English Proficiency — Carriers whose drivers were cited under 49 CFR § 391.11(b)(2), by carrier and state.
Methodology — Where the data comes from and how the Safety Score and Risk Grade are built.
Showing 1–25 of 147
Page 1 / 6
2025-08-1504:08FORT WAYNE, IN1vehicle
I- 469· County 003
Clear · Dark – not lighted · Dry
Two-way, divided, unprotected median · Partial control
Sequence: 1:6:NONCOLLISION:EXPLOSION OR FIRE;2:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT
Reported by ALLEN SD
Tow-away
2025-06-1313:43PRINCETON, IN2vehicles
W BROADWAY· County 051
Clear · Daylight · Dry
Two-way, divided, unprotected median · Partial control
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by PRINCETON PD
3 injured
Tow-away
2024-09-1014:38GREENCASTLE, IN2vehicles
N JACKSON ST· County 133
Clear · Daylight · Dry
Two-way, not divided · Partial control
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by GREENCASTLE PD
Tow-away
2024-07-2513:01WEST LAFAYETTE, IN4vehicles
SAGAMORE PKWY N· County 157
Clear · Daylight · Dry
Partial control
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by WEST LAFAYETTE PD
1 injured
Tow-away
2024-05-1400:50ROBARDS, KY1vehicle
I 0069· County 101
Sequence: 1:19:COLLISION WITH WORK ZONE MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT
Reported by KY STATE POLICE POST 16
Tow-away
2024-03-0510:32DAVENPORT, IA1vehicle
I 280 E· County 163
Sequence: 3:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT;4:17:COLLISION INVOLVING ANIMAL;1:6:NONCOLLISION:EXPLOSION OR FIRE;2:6:NONCOLLISION:EXPLOSION OR FIRE
Reported by IOWA STATE PATROL CMVU
Tow-away
2024-02-2809:00TEKONSHA TWP, MI1vehicle
OLD US 27· County 025
Sequence: 1:19:COLLISION WITH WORK ZONE MAINTENANCE EQUIPMENT
Reported by MSP Marshall
Tow-away
2024-01-1613:51IA2vehicles
310TH ST· County 123
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by MAHASKA COUNTY SHERIFF
Tow-away
2023-08-1815:39SEBREE, KY1vehicle
I 0069· County 233
Sequence: 1:6:NONCOLLISION:EXPLOSION OR FIRE;2:6:NONCOLLISION:EXPLOSION OR FIRE
Reported by WEBSTER COUNTY SHERIFF DEPT.
Tow-away
2022-09-0907:45HOPKINSVILLE, KY2vehicles
KY1007· County 047
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by HOPKINSVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT
Tow-away
2022-08-1009:23PENDLETON, IN2vehicles
N PENDLETON AVE· County 095
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by PENDLETON PD
Tow-away
2022-07-1219:10DOUGLAS TWP, IL4vehicles
I-57 S/B· County 049
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT;3:6:NONCOLLISION:EXPLOSION OR FIRE;2:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by Illinois State Police
Tow-away
2021-10-2710:56LASALLE, IL2vehicles
3RD ST· County 099
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by Lasalle Police Dept
Tow-away
2021-10-2612:30WATSEKA, IL2vehicles
WALNUT· County 075
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by Watseka Police Dept
Tow-away
2021-05-1306:20KASKASKIA TWP, IL2vehicles
US-51· County 051
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by Fayette Co Sheriff
1 injured
Tow-away
2021-05-1211:20LADOGA, IN2vehicles
SR234E· County 107
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by MONTGOMERY SD
Tow-away
2020-02-2606:30NON-CITY OR UNINCORPORATE, MO4vehicles
IS 70· County 053
Sequence: 1:98:OTHER;4:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT;3:98:OTHER;2:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by MOMHPFF00
1 injured
Tow-away
2019-08-1310:03PONETO, IN2vehicles
SR3· County 179
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by WELLS SD
Tow-away
2019-02-2114:22EVANSVILLE, IN3vehicles
US41N· County 163
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by EVANSVILLE PD
Tow-away
2018-09-1315:55RUSHVILLE, IN3vehicles
SR3S· County 139
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by RUSH SD
Tow-away
2018-04-0413:35ANGOLA, IN2vehicles
CR100N· County 151
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by STEUBEN SD
Tow-away
2017-03-2911:20LA PORTE, IN3vehicles
SR39· County 091
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by LAPORTE PD
1 injured
2017-02-1010:23CAMDEN, OH2vehicles
US 127· County 135
Sequence: 2:1:NONCOLLISION:RAN OFF ROAD;3:3:NONCOLLISION:OVERTURN (ROLLOVER);1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT;4:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT
Reported by DAYTON OSHP
1 injured
Tow-away
2016-08-1015:43LAWRENCE, IN2vehicles
SHADELAND· County 097
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by LAWRENCE PD
1 injured
2015-06-2316:07DECATUR, IN2vehicles
SR124W· County 001
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by ADAMS SD
1 injured
Tow-away
Showing latest 25 of 27 crashes
Current policies
(1)
SELECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA
91X · 1 · #S2351416
Coverage: $0 – $750,000
Effective 2019-01-04 → —
Active
Insurance history
Snapshot 2026-09-25
Estimated measures · FMCSA SMS v3.21 method · data through 2026-10-30 · calculated 2026-11-02