Carrierintel
FS

FIVE STAR TRANSPORTATION LLC

Carrierintel Safety Score: 76/100. 2 inspection violations in 12 months. Last inspected Jun 2026.

DOT 1473865MC 556503ActiveMotor CarrierInterstateZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANYNEW CARLISLE, IN

COMPANY

Authority since
2006-04-25
MCS-150
2026-05-06 · 3,695,764 mi (2024)
Fleet
19 units · 180 trailers · 45 drivers
Annual mileage (VMT)
3,695,764 mi (2024)

ADDRESS

Physical
54374 SMILAX RD
NEW CARLISLE, IN 46552-9751
Mailing
Same as physical

CONTACT

Phone
5746548058
Email
rmartens@fivestarsheets.com

OFFICERS

Primary Officer
ANDY SCHAEFER
Title
PRESIDENT

OPERATION & CARGO

Operation classification
Authorized For Hire
Specialty
Household Goods Mover
Cargo types
8
General FreightHousehold GoodsMetal: Sheets, Coils, RollsBuilding MaterialsMachinery, Large ObjectsBeveragesPaper ProductsConstruction
Self-reported by the company on its latest MCS-150 filing (FMCSA census). Reflects what the carrier is authorized and equipped to haul, not actual recent loads. Specialty is our summary of the declared cargo mix.
AUTHORITY
246 mo
Active authority
INSURANCE
1 active
ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY
RISK GRADE
Minimal Risk
0 risk factors · 5 strengths
OOS RATE
6.7%
3 / 45 inspections

Carrierintel Safety Score

Rolling 12-month heuristic based on inspections, OOS, violations, crashes & fatalities. Not the official FMCSA SMS score.

76
out of 100
Good
Markers: OOS inspection Crash Fatality

Fleet vs Reality

last 12 months · power-unit VINs from roadside inspections
Declared (MCS-150)
19 power units
Unique power units seen
7
+ 7 trailer VINs
Inspections
7
Discrepancy
0.4x

Minimal Risk

0 risk factors · 5 strengths · 5 data points

SAFETY PERFORMANCE

Crash Record
27 crashes · 0 fatal · 5 with injuries · 27 tow-away
Clean Inspection Rate
93% — 42 clean of 45 inspections
Out-of-Service Rate
6.7% — driver OOS 1 insp., vehicle OOS 2 insp.

COMPLIANCE & AUTHORITY

USDOT Registration
Status: Active
Operating Authority
Active: Motor Carrier
Out-of-service orders
None on record
Authority Events
13 historical event(s) on file
MCS-150 Filing
Last filed 2026-05-06

INSURANCE

Active Coverage
1 policy(ies) on file · total max coverage $750,000

SUMMARY

Low OOS rate 4% (last 24 mo)
Low crash rate (2.6 per 100 trucks/yr)
Low violation rate (0.3/insp)
93% clean inspections
Active insurance on file

INDUSTRY REPORTS

  • ELD Tampering — Carriers cited for ELD tampering under 49 CFR § 395.8(e), by carrier and state.
  • Top Violations — The ten most-cited FMCSA violation codes of the last 30 days.
  • Phantom Fleets — Declared power units against the vehicles seen at roadside inspections.
  • English Proficiency — Carriers whose drivers were cited under 49 CFR § 391.11(b)(2), by carrier and state.
  • Methodology — Where the data comes from and how the Safety Score and Risk Grade are built.

Other motor carriers in this city

More carriers in Indiana

All Indiana carriers →Browse every state →