Carrierintel Safety Score: 71/100. 24 inspection violations in 12 months. Last inspected Sep 2026.
DOT 1132380MC 638825ActiveMotor CarrierIntrastate Non-HazmatACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY · $750,000 · 1 policyMANTUA, OH
COMPANY
Authority since
2008-03-21
MCS-150
2025-01-31 · 1,510,000 mi (2025)
Fleet
27 units · 13 trailers · 26 drivers
Annual mileage (VMT)
1,510,000 mi (2025)
ADDRESS
Physical
9551 ELLIMAN MANTUA, OH 44255
Mailing
PO BOX 670261 NORTHFIELD, OH 44067
CONTACT
Phone
4402323700
Email
amy@carrbros.net
OFFICERS
Primary Officer
DUANE A CARR JR
Title
PRESIDENT
OPERATION & CARGO
Operation classification
Authorized For Hire · Exempt For Hire
Specialty
Construction & Building Materials
Cargo types
4
Building MaterialsCommodities Dry BulkConstructionWater Well
Self-reported by the company on its latest MCS-150 filing (FMCSA census). Reflects what the carrier is authorized and equipped to haul, not actual recent loads. Specialty is our summary of the declared cargo mix.
AUTHORITY
223 mo
Active authority
INSURANCE
1 active
ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY
RISK GRADE
Minimal Risk
0 risk factors · 3 strengths
OOS RATE
8.8%
3 / 34 inspections
Carrierintel Safety Score
Rolling 12-month heuristic based on inspections, OOS, violations, crashes & fatalities. Not the official FMCSA SMS score.
71
out of 100
Good
Markers: OOS inspection Crash Fatality
Fleet vs Reality
last 12 months · power-unit VINs from roadside inspections
1 policy(ies) on file · total max coverage $750,000
SUMMARY
Low crash rate (1.9 per 100 trucks/yr)
91% clean inspections
Active insurance on file
INDUSTRY REPORTS
ELD Tampering — Carriers cited for ELD tampering under 49 CFR § 395.8(e), by carrier and state.
Top Violations — The ten most-cited FMCSA violation codes of the last 30 days.
Phantom Fleets — Declared power units against the vehicles seen at roadside inspections.
English Proficiency — Carriers whose drivers were cited under 49 CFR § 391.11(b)(2), by carrier and state.
Methodology — Where the data comes from and how the Safety Score and Risk Grade are built.
Showing 1–25 of 34
Page 1 / 2
2024-12-0207:15BEDFORD HEIGHTS, OH2vehicles
IR 480· County 035
Clear · Dawn · Wet
One-way
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by BEDFORD HEIGHTS
Tow-away
2023-09-1915:16AKRON, OH2vehicles
I 77 HW· County 153
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by AKRON POLICE DEPARTMENT
1 injured
Tow-away
2022-11-0909:06STREETSBORO, OH2vehicles
SR 14· County 133
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT
Reported by STREETSBORO
Tow-away
2022-09-0211:07OAKWOOD, OH2vehicles
FORBES RD· County 035
Sequence: 1:20:COLLISION INVOLVING OTHER MOVABLE OBJECT;2:6:NONCOLLISION:EXPLOSION OR FIRE
Reported by OAKWOOD VILLAGE
1 injured
Tow-away
2018-02-2105:52AKRON, OH2vehicles
IR 0077S· County 153
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by AKRON PD
Tow-away
2016-04-2513:33STREETSBORO, OH2vehicles
SR 14· County 133
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by STREETSBORO POLICE
1 injured
2014-09-0309:18FREEDOM (TOWNSHIP OF), OH2vehicles
SR 303· County 133
Sequence: 3:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT;1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT;2:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT;4:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT
Reported by RAVENNA OSP
Tow-away
2014-08-1208:48WARRENSVILLE HTS, OH2vehicles
IR 480· County 035
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by WARRENSVILLE HEIGHTS
Tow-away
2013-05-2406:23Canton, OH1vehicle
Georgetown RD· County 151
Sequence: 3:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT;2:3:NONCOLLISION:OVERTURN (ROLLOVER);1:5:NONCOLLISION:CARGO LOSS OR SHIFT
Reported by Massillon Osp
Tow-away
2012-08-2714:34BEDFORD HEIGHTS, OH3vehicles
0480· County 035
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by Bedford Heights
Tow-away
2012-02-0111:43Franklin, OH2vehicles
0261· County 133
Sequence: 2:98:OTHER;1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT;4:98:OTHER;3:98:OTHER
Reported by Ravenna OSP
Tow-away
2010-03-2412:10CLEVELAND, OH1vehicle
0090· County 035
Sequence: 1:3:NONCOLLISION:OVERTURN (ROLLOVER)
Reported by Cleveland Police Department
1 injured
Tow-away
2008-09-0207:50CLEVELAND, OH2vehicles
HURON· County 035
Sequence: 2:98:OTHER;1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT;4:98:OTHER;3:98:OTHER
Reported by Cleveland Police Department
1 injured
Tow-away
2007-08-2712:4104878, OH2vehicles
FORBES· County 035
Sequence: 2:98:OTHER;1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT;4:98:OTHER;3:98:OTHER
Reported by Bedford Police Department
1 injured
2006-08-0511:37NEWBURY, OH3vehicles
SR0044· County 055
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT;2:8:NONCOLLISION:CROSS MEDIAN/CENTERLINE;4:18:COLLISION INVOLVING FIXED OBJECT;3:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by CHARDON OSP
4 fatal
2 injured
Tow-away
2005-02-2511:41STREETSBORO, OH2vehicles
SR0014· County 133
Sequence: 2:98:OTHER;1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT;4:98:OTHER;3:98:OTHER
Reported by STREETSBORO
1 injured
2003-07-1809:06STREETSBORO, OH2vehicles
IR0480· County 133
Sequence: 1:13:COLLISION INVOLVING MOTOR VEHICLE IN TRANSPORT
Reported by STREETSBORO
1 injured
Current policies
(1)
ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY
BMC-91X · 1 · #CA-L21091
Coverage: $0 – $750,000
Effective 2012-04-29 → —
Active
Insurance history
Snapshot 2026-09-25
Estimated measures · FMCSA SMS v3.21 method · data through 2026-10-15 · calculated 2026-10-18
Unsafe Driving
intrastate
Measure
1.4
↓ avg 2.31
Percentile
—
24 insp · 6 viol
Hours-of-Service Compliance
intrastate
Measure
0.00
est.
↓ avg 0.58
Snapshot 2026-09-25: 0
Percentile
—
24 insp · 0 viol
Driver Fitness
intrastate
Measure
0.00
est.
↓ avg 0.85
Snapshot 2026-09-25: 0
Percentile
—
24 insp · 0 viol
Controlled Substances/Alcohol
intrastate
Measure
0.00
est.
↓ avg 0.04
Snapshot 2026-09-25: 0
Percentile
—
24 insp · 0 viol
Vehicle Maintenance
intrastate
Measure
5.84
est.
↓ avg 6.29
Snapshot 2026-09-25: 5.73
Percentile
—
24 insp · 7 viol
GRANTED
2008-03-21 · Motor Carrier of Property (Except Household Goods)